Primera División · Clausura - 12
FBC Melgar 4–2 Deportivo Garcilaso
Sat 17 Oct 2026 · 23:00 UTC · Estadio Monumental de la UNSA, Arequipa
FBC MelgarTeam 1735
Deportivo GarcilasoTeam 1622Match story
FBC Melgar · draw · Deportivo GarcilasoBefore kick-off: 47% · 28% · 24%
Last reading, 90+6': 100% · 0% · 0%
Live chances from PlayerElo's pre-match model and the current score.
- Nicolas Quagliata 39'
- Johnny Vidales 62' (pen)
- Bernardo Cuesta 73'
- Cristian Bordacahar 76'
We gave FBC Melgar 47% to win: they did.
- 5'Facundo Castelli 1622 −17
Deportivo Garcilaso:Facundo Castelli 1622 −17 - 9'Facundo Castelli 1622 −17 assist Pablo Labrin 1531 0
Deportivo Garcilaso:Facundo Castelli 1622 −17 assist Pablo Labrin 1531 0 - Nicolas Quagliata 1771 +30 assist Matías Lazo 1819 +2339'
FBC Melgar:Nicolas Quagliata 1771 +30 assist Matías Lazo 1819 +23 - 57'Francisco Arancibia 1633 −22 assist Pablo Labrin 1531 0
Deportivo Garcilaso:Francisco Arancibia 1633 −22 assist Pablo Labrin 1531 0 - 60'Carlos Ramos 1646 −8
Deportivo Garcilaso:Carlos Ramos 1646 −8 - Johnny Vidales 1644 +8 (pen.)62'
FBC Melgar:Johnny Vidales 1644 +8 (pen.) - Nicolas Quagliata 1771 +3064'
FBC Melgar:Nicolas Quagliata 1771 +30 - Horacio Orzan 1527 −15* for Nelson Cabanillas 1767 +868'
FBC Melgar:Horacio Orzan 1527 −15* for Nelson Cabanillas 1767 +8 - 71'Fernando Pacheco 1662 −2 for Facundo Castelli 1622 −17
Deportivo Garcilaso:Fernando Pacheco 1662 −2 for Facundo Castelli 1622 −17 - Bernardo Cuesta 1649 +3973'
FBC Melgar:Bernardo Cuesta 1649 +39 - Lautaro Guzmán 1687 +2 for Johnny Vidales 1644 +874'
FBC Melgar:Lautaro Guzmán 1687 +2 for Johnny Vidales 1644 +8 - Cristian Bordacahar 1659 +37 assist Horacio Orzan 1527 −15*76'
FBC Melgar:Cristian Bordacahar 1659 +37 assist Horacio Orzan 1527 −15* - Franco Zanelatto 1666 −6* for Cristian Bordacahar 1659 +3781'
FBC Melgar:Franco Zanelatto 1666 −6* for Cristian Bordacahar 1659 +37 - Jesús Alcantar 1608 +2 for Kevin Minda 1771 +982'
FBC Melgar:Jesús Alcantar 1608 +2 for Kevin Minda 1771 +9 - 83'Claudio Torrejón 1546 −13* for Carlos Ramos 1646 −8
Deportivo Garcilaso:Claudio Torrejón 1546 −13* for Carlos Ramos 1646 −8 - 83'Adrian Ascues 1506 0 for Pablo Labrin 1531 0
Deportivo Garcilaso:Adrian Ascues 1506 0 for Pablo Labrin 1531 0 - 83'Christopher Olivares 1619 −1 for Beto Da Silva 1678 −11
Deportivo Garcilaso:Christopher Olivares 1619 −1 for Beto Da Silva 1678 −11 - 88'José Anthony Rosell 1354 −10* for Xavi Moreno Layme 1577 −2
Deportivo Garcilaso:José Anthony Rosell 1354 −10* for Xavi Moreno Layme 1577 −2
Line-ups
Elo change from this match, next to the Elo after it.
Before kick-off: 47% · 28% · 24%(FBC Melgar · draw · Deportivo Garcilaso)
Our most likely score was 1–1 (14%); the result 4–2 had 1%.
- Average value of the starting XI: FBC Melgar €600K, Deportivo Garcilaso €354K.
- Style contrast in possession (Primera División): FBC Melgar ranked #2 of 18, Deportivo Garcilaso #18.
- FBC Melgar were unbeaten in their last 5 matches.
Form
Last five matches; the number is the team Elo of the eleven that started.
FBC Melgar
4th in Primera División · 47 pts from 28
- 11 OctDUniversitario Peru Primera Division1727
- 20 SepDSport Boys Peru Primera Division1720
- 12 SepWCusco Peru Primera Division1711
- 6 SepWADT Peru Primera Division1710
- 23 AugDAlianza Lima Peru Primera Division1712
Deportivo Garcilaso
3rd in Primera División · 48 pts from 28
- 10 OctLSport Huancayo Peru Primera Division1667
- 19 SepWUniversitario Peru Primera Division1618
- 13 SepLSport Boys Peru Primera Division1626
- 6 SepWAtletico Grau Peru Primera Division1609
- 30 AugWAlianza Lima Peru Primera Division1601
Season outlook
From the Primera División simulation, before this match.
| Club | Pts now | Pred. pts | Title | Top 4 | Bottom 3 | Most likely |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FBC Melgar | 47 /28 | 57.6 | <1% | 81% | 0% | 3rd |
| Deportivo Garcilaso | 48 /28 | 57.2 | <1% | 73% | 0% | 4th |
Each bar is one finishing position, 1st on the left to 18th on the right; the taller the bar, the likelier that finish.
Players to watch
Highest EAR = Elo Above Replacement, football's version of baseball's WAR (Wins Above Replacement). Every rated match scores a player against the average performance for their position: better adds to EAR, worse subtracts. EAR180 adds up the last 180 days (current form); EAR career adds up every rated match. Our predictions add EAR180 to a player's Elo, about 37 Elo points per EAR point. (Elo Above Replacement over the last 180 days) in each starting eleven. Elo after each match, last three years.

FBC Melgar · EAR = Elo Above Replacement, football's version of baseball's WAR (Wins Above Replacement). Every rated match scores a player against the average performance for their position: better adds to EAR, worse subtracts. EAR180 adds up the last 180 days (current form); EAR career adds up every rated match. Our predictions add EAR180 to a player's Elo, about 37 Elo points per EAR point. +4.2 (Good) · Elo 1741

Deportivo Garcilaso · EAR = Elo Above Replacement, football's version of baseball's WAR (Wins Above Replacement). Every rated match scores a player against the average performance for their position: better adds to EAR, worse subtracts. EAR180 adds up the last 180 days (current form); EAR career adds up every rated match. Our predictions add EAR180 to a player's Elo, about 37 Elo points per EAR point. +4.5 (Elite) · Elo 1656
Team Elo history
Starting-eleven Team Elo in league matches, last three years.
Coach Elo history
Elo after each match, last three years (the whole career if shorter).
Coach DNA: possession-based · low-block
Coach DNA: –
Playing style
How both clubs play against their own league (2024–2026).
FBC Melgar: balanced profile (how Miguel Ángel Rondelli plays) · Deportivo Garcilaso: direct (how Lisandro Greppo plays)
* Includes our monthly adjustment: every month we take a little off each player's Elo to keep ratings from inflating.